There are various production processes used in the field of plastic processing. The two most widely used procedures are extrusion and injection molding. They employ multiple tools and methods, but they give similar results. The manufacturing process differs depending on whether you are molding plastic products for industrial, commercial, or medical applications. This guide will discuss the main differences between these plastic procedures and the best one suitable for your project.
The major differences between extrusion and injection molding are the fundamentals of the two approaches, compatibility, strength, and precision, vary significantly. All of these elements work together to affect the process' overall price and duration, affecting both techniques' overall costs and potential.
Extrusion and injection molding have almost the same process. The similarities between injection molding and extrusion stop at the point at which plastic is heated to cause it to deform and assume the shape of a particular dye. The final procedures are different, so they have different approaches.
For instance, extrusion melts the plastic and forces it through a specific form. As a result, the extrudate, also known as the product of extrusion, assumes the shape of the dye and cools to harden.
The procedure for injection molding is distinct. Although the plastic melts, no dye or other form is forced. Instead, a cavity-filled injection mold is placed inside the liquified plastic. The plastic is ultimately ejected for the following cycle after cooling inside the mold to solidify.
In terms of precision, injection molding is way better than extrusion. The complex design of 3D items is much more suited to injection molding. However, managing design complexity requires a lengthy cast preparation process. Extrusion produces outcomes quickly but could be more precise.
Almost all thermoplastics and most thermoset polymers are produced by injection molding. This makes it possible to produce durable and reusable materials like nylon and acrylic. However, thermoplastics like PVC can only be produced by extrusion.
Injection molding depends on a machine with an injection and clamping mechanism. Moreover, another prerequisite of the process is tooling with the appropriate design cavity. However, extrusion only needs a non-rubber machine.
Injection molding and extrusion work well with plastics. However, injection molding is more suitable for complex closed 3D shapes, like vehicle interior room components. These plastic components have a complex initial dye, increasing the capital costs but remaining operational for many cycles.
Contrarily, extrusion is ideal for continuous objects or repeatable parts with the same cross-section. For instance, PVC frames, pipes, and similar objects with continuous cross-sections will almost always rely on extrusion for production.
Cost-wise, extrusion and injection molding are very different from one another. Injection molding is more costly due to the price of the mold. Depending on the design's complexity, machining or 3D printing is required for the mold. The expense of an injection mold is also significantly influenced by the material. The mold will last longer with superior materials but will cost more.
On the other hand, the extrusion procedure is much less complicated and easily handles 2D shapes. Because of this, the process's running costs are reduced while being unaffected by economies of scale. In addition, the total setup expenses for extrusion can be quite high.
Injection molding transforms plastic resins into complex plastics with a mold, an injector, pressure, heat, and heat. At a suitable pressure and temperature, a good flowing melt will conform to the shape of any well-built mold to create finished plastic components of the highest caliber.
There are many advantages of the molding process. Some of which include:
● Excellent Accuracy
The consistency and precision injection molding provides are two main benefits. Injection molds typically have a tolerance of +/- 0.005 inches, but it is possible to decrease this tolerance further and increase the part's overall precision.
● Compatible With Different Plastics
The almost universal compatibility of injection molding with plastics is another feature that makes it superb. Since virtually all types of plastics can be used in the process, it is exceptional and offers greater versatility in product creation.
● Enhanced Productivity
This feature depends on two things. First, numerous parts can be processed by injection molding machines in a single cycle, improving economies of scale and increasing production effectiveness. Second, most injection-molded components don't require any post-processing, making them market-ready as soon as they are released. Thereby increasing overall productivity by bringing out products that are available for market sooner.
Even though injection molding has several advantages, it still has some disadvantages. Here are some of the drawbacks;
● Expensive Setup
There are numerous costs associated with setting up the injection molding procedure, so it is expensive. The cost of the machine, the mold, and other related expenses can add up fast. For small to medium-sized manufacturing units, price is a worry.
● Long Initial Lead Times
Preparing injection molds takes a lot of time and money, a crucial prerequisite for this procedure. This lengthens the project's total lead times and could have a detrimental effect on performance.
● Unsuitable for Low-Volume Production
It is possible for injection molding to be very cost-effective, but only if enough parts are made. The process can be quite costly for low-volume production due to the associated costs, which are primarily connected to mold creation.
Extrusion is a general procedure in which a liquid plastic passes through a specific cross-section and takes on its final shape. For the plastic to maintain its shape as it emerges from the dye during the extrusion process, there are a few additional requirements linked to temperature and pressure.
These are some of the pros of the extrusion process:
● Reduced Cost
The best feature of the plastic extrusion method is the overall impact on prices. The technique offers consistent, quick, and high-quality outcomes in the shortest time, making it the best option for non-complex 2D parts.
● Outstanding Surface Finish
There is no need for post-processing after plastic molding. A small opening is used to push plastic through it under intense pressure, which prevents any air bubbles or other imperfections from remaining inside. As a result, the surface polish it provides is still excellent.
● Suitable for High-volume Production
Extrusion is the best option for high-volume manufacturing since it can constantly produce numerous components with the same design. It's crucial to remember that the process offers a different degree of scale economy than injection molding.
Here are some of the drawbacks of the extrusion process:
● Part-size Inaccuracies
One of its main drawbacks is the extrusion method's inability to accommodate variations in the cross-section or size. Any modifications would require a different color, which might result in delays.
● Setup Cost
Extrusion has more restrictions than injection molding, so the total set-up costs are quite high. The overall expenses might go over budget as a result of this.
● Environmental Effect
The hot plastic used in extrusion and injection molding raises several environmental issues. However, extruded goods are not durable, which amplifies the process's adverse ecological effects.
This is an important debate in the plastic manufacturing industry. However, there’s no victor between the two. Both procedures have advantages and disadvantages, but the best option depends on the application's requirements. When deciding between molding and extrusion, there are a number of significant factors to consider, including the design's complexity and the procedure's capabilities. However, because many projects are time-sensitive and necessitate the ideal balancing of quality and price, the cost needed for quality and the available time is also equally essential.
Depending on the particulars of the application, either procedure may be the best option. A complicated design may make extrusion impossible in some circumstances. However, services for injection molding are exempt from that limitation. Extrusion can be a good option, though, as it produces high-quality results quickly in many situations where expense and time are the main constraints.
Finding the perfect manufacturing partner can be quite complicated. That’s why Ares Prototyping is here to help. WithAres Prototyping, you get high-quality, on-demand custom parts with expert prototyping and production capabilities, online instant quotes, automated DFM analysis in seconds, and quality parts shipped in days.
Our team of specialists can also assist you in choosing the best process in case you’re unsure of what’s suitable for your project. Additionally, we manufacture plastic injection and extrusion molds, perform overmolding and insert molding, trade-in numerous categories of use-specific molds, and offer a wide range of plastic. To get a quote and start the process, upload the designs and other job requirements. After sending the mold into production, we'll examine your designs and produce a mold flow study, delivering the item you need to your entryway. The best aspect is that you can be sure of the level of quality. Choose Ares Prototyping and set your mind at ease concerning the manufacturing of your project.